AITA for refusing to give my mom the only 'gift' she wanted for Xmas?

AITA for refusing to give my mom the only ‘gift’ she wanted for Xmas?

For years, my sister has made my life unbearable, but this year, she crossed a line I can’t forgive. Her obsession with my oldest daughter became toxic, and her need to control every aspect of my parenting spiraled into something dangerous.

AITA for refusing to give my mom the only 'gift' she wanted for Xmas?
Source: Reddit

It started when my sister demanded to be involved in every “first” for my daughter, claiming she deserved it because she’d “never had kids of her own.” She even tried to force her way into the delivery room when only one person was allowed. Over time, it became clear she wasn’t just overstepping she was trying to position herself as my daughter’s mother.

AITA for refusing to give my mom the only 'gift' she wanted for Xmas?
Source: Reddit

Things escalated to the point that she threatened to call CPS on me after I refused to let her take my daughter for an entire summer. This wasn’t an idle threat; she also said she’d bring a gun to my mom’s house to harm my fiancé. That was the breaking point. My fiancé and I packed up our lives, moving halfway across the country to escape her toxic behavior.

AITA for refusing to give my mom the only 'gift' she wanted for Xmas?
Source: Reddit

But she didn’t stop. A few months after our move, on my daughter’s fifth birthday, my sister made good on her CPS threat. She filed a report accusing us of sexual abuse and neglect, basing it on absurd claims like my younger daughter having chocolate ice cream on her face. She even used my autistic daughter’s diaper rash as part of her fabricated story. I know it was her because she bragged about it.

AITA for refusing to give my mom the only 'gift' she wanted for Xmas?
Source: Reddit

This wasn’t just a cruel act of revenge for taking “her” kids away it was an attempt to destroy my family. After that, I went no contact with her completely. I couldn’t let someone who tried to harm my children remain in their lives.

AITA for refusing to give my mom the only 'gift' she wanted for Xmas?
Source: Reddit

Today, on Christmas, I called my mom so the kids could wish her a merry Christmas and show her their gifts. The call went well until my mom pulled me aside and asked for one “favor”: let my kids talk to my sister “just for a few minutes.” She begged, saying it was the only thing she wanted for Christmas and that we could go back to no contact afterward.

AITA for refusing to give my mom the only 'gift' she wanted for Xmas?
Source: Reddit

I refused. I told her I wouldn’t put my children through that. The last time my kids saw my sister, they begged and cried for weeks to talk to her again, not understanding why they couldn’t. I wasn’t about to reopen that wound, not for a holiday request.

AITA for refusing to give my mom the only 'gift' she wanted for Xmas?
Source: Reddit

My mom broke down in tears, saying I was ruining Christmas and asking why I couldn’t let it go, just this once. But how could I? My sister tried to tear my family apart. She hurt us in ways that are impossible to forgive.

AITA for refusing to give my mom the only 'gift' she wanted for Xmas?
Source: Reddit

Now, I’m left questioning if I was too harsh. My mom only asked for one thing, but was it really worth risking my children’s peace and safety? Or was I right to stand my ground, even if it broke her heart?

AITA for refusing to give my mom the only 'gift' she wanted for Xmas?
Source: Reddit

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *